top of page
Search
Writer's pictureBrimstone
Sep 2, 202322 min read

Brimstone's Guide to 33 of the Best Long Island Restaurants and Hidden Gems

Updated: Aug 4


For those of you finding me for the first time... WELCOME and thanks for dropping in via my BrimBLOG! If you are unfamiliar with who I am and what I do, you can definitely visit my Official Biography if at all interested - In a nutshell, I've been in entertainment for over forty years, toured a LOT and when it comes to food... let's just say I know what's what! For those of you who DO know me... you know what's up - Welcome back. Now, I have lived on Long Island my entire life - So when I tell you I LOVE the places below... it is from MANY years of experience weeding out the garbage and indulging in the BEST Long Island has to offer! I am essentially giving you my little nuggets of gold - the keys to my comprehensive guide of experiencing the Long Island dining scene; as well as some of my other favorite places to explore when I'm not out on tour. As a lover of great food and exciting, unique locations, I've curated a list of my RIDE-OR-DIE spots that are sure to tantalize your taste buds and ignite your sense of adventure. So, without further ado, let's dive into the culinary delights and unique experiences that my stomping grounds has to offer (No particular order).

 

1. Toast Coffeehouse

Address: 9 S Pk Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Phone: (631) 647-9560


Albeit they have multiple locations... my personal favorite is the one located in the heart of Bay Shore, Toast Coffeehouse is the perfect spot to kick-start your day with a delicious breakfast or enjoy a cozy brunch. Their diverse menu, featuring an array of delectable dishes, ensures there's something for everyone. I've been a HUGE fan of Toast for a REALLY long time. Not only are the locations visually stimulating; but I've never had a bad meal there! Crazy combinations that will tantalize your tastebuds, portions where you can actually justify the cost and the coffee is incredible. Seriously folks - If you are a lover of coffee, they always have a variety of different tasty treats to wake up with! Polite and knowledgeable staff. Very highly recommended - one of the BEST spots for breakfast on Long Island.


 

2. Lucharitos

Address: 872 Walt Whitman Rd, Melville, NY 11747

Phone: (631) 421-2317


For those craving a taste of Mexican flavor, Lucharitos in Melville is a must-visit. Again, they have multiple locations - I've only dined at this location though! This vibrant eatery serves up mouthwatering tacos, burritos, and other Mexican street food favorites, along with a selection of refreshing margaritas to quench your thirst. Now, as a former Professional Wrestler - I enjoyed the overall theme of the restaurant itself; however I'm thrilled that it's not just a gimmick... the food is AWESOME! Wings are tender and fell off the bone - great flavor behavior and true to the menu description. Big WIN is the Nacho Trio - HUGE mountain of nachos with a sampling of three meats (beef, pork and chicken)... I'd recommend. The Street Corn fries are also WINNING! Portions are all on point - No complaints. Server and staff are all pleasant and helpful. Highly recommended - Especially for wrestling fans! Just don't powerbomb anyone through a table... that's just not cool.


 

3. Sushi Time 560

Address: 560 Stewart Avenue, Bethpage, NY 11714

Phone: (516) 513-1515


Satisfy your sushi cravings at Sushi Time 560, a hidden gem in Bethpage. With an extensive menu of fresh and creative sushi rolls, sashimi, and other Japanese delicacies, this place is a haven for sushi enthusiasts. I've been dining here for years now and it's simply the best option for all-you-can-eat sushi in Nassau County on Long Island. The staff is great and the quality of food is top notch. - fresh and delicious! Pricing runs about $27.99 on Weekdays and $29.99 on Weekends. It's also a BYOB spot - So feel free to bring in your own alcohol to enjoy with your meal! Know before you go and you'll have an INCREDIBLE meal and full belly!


 

4. Hunan Dynasty

Address: 2292 Hempstead Tpke, East Meadow, NY 11554

Phone: (516) 731-4100


For those seeking truly authentic Chinese cuisine, Hunan Dynasty in East Meadow is the go-to spot. From traditional dishes to chef's specials, their menu showcases a range of flavors that will transport you to the heart of China. Legit - I have been indulging in their food for over twenty years!!! Always been a fantastic Chinese restaurant. Polite staff and delicious cuisine. Best authentic Chinese food in the immediate area. My go to is their General Tso's Chicken which is served crispy and spicy with a touch of sweetness. I would also suggest the Boneless Ribs and the Pu Pu Platter (always a WIN) that comes with spring roll, spare rib, beef stick, chicken wings, fantail shrimp and chicken stick - complete with a flaming skillet. Closed on Monday's and ONLY open until 9pm on the other days - So be aware and get there early! Must visit!!!


 

5. The Witches Brew

Address: 311 Hempstead Turnpike, West Hempstead, NY 11552

Phone: (516) 489-9482


Embrace your inner witch or wizard at The Witches Brew, a quirky and enchanting coffeehouse in West Hempstead. This mystical spot offers a variety of coffees, teas, and delectable treats, all served in a whimsical atmosphere. Cool environment. Relaxed; but very metal simultaneously. Seating indoors and outdoors on a variety of different sofas, couches and vintage looking chairs. Probably 100 different coffees and espressos to choose from. Vegan menu that's worth the visit. Hoison Brusslesprouts are a WIN. The Meatless Chicken Sandwich and Philly Cheesesteak are also both incredible. Desserts? What... off the chain! Been there over twenty years - Probably be there at least another twenty more. Very well worth the visit. Keep in mind - CASH ONLY... so be prepared!!! Also, the parking situation there is sketchy - so just expect that you won't find a spot as soon as you pull up.


 

6. Sabor a Colombia Restaurant

Address: 2953 Hempstead Tpke, Levittown, NY 11756

Phone: (516) 513-1520


Experience the vibrant flavors of Colombian cuisine at Sabor a Colombia Restaurant in Levittown. From savory empanadas to hearty Bandeja Paisa, this restaurant will take you on a culinary journey through the diverse flavors of Colombia. If I am being honest - I was NOT a fan at first... they had been in Hicksville and then in a different spot around the corner in Levittown, it was just not consistent and not, well... good. However, this NEW location is magical, a completely new outlook. The spot overall is gorgeous, they even have karaoke! I've had the food take-out and in house and it was legit a HUGE step above what was offered prior. They had good deals on uber-eats, so I gave them an opportunity.- Glad I did. I'm impressed with this glow up and you will be too! If you have a few people eating - Grab the Picada de la Casa aka House Deep Fry Platter which is $40 and comes with a HEAPING mound of grilled top round steak, pork loin, sausage, pork ribs, fried pork skin, potatoes, cassava, fried green plantains, blood sausage and corn cake. WINNING. Recommended.


 

7. Brooklyn Dip & Burger

Address: 1850 Front St, East Meadow, NY 11554

Phone: (516) 222-8000


Indulge in the ultimate comfort food experience at Brooklyn Dip & Burger. Known for their mouthwatering burgers and delectable dipping sauces, this East Meadow gem is a haven for burger aficionados. Great little burger place nestled in the middle of a small strip mall. Definitely a solid find - the burgers are made well and they're affordable too. If you can eat - take the challenge... 6 patties, each with cheese, and fries for only $25. Considering the regular burgers are around $18 - you're getting a great deal and enough to eat! Furthermore, the wings here are a WIN. Haven't had a bad wing there yet... pretty impressive. Highly recommended for a good bite to eat.


 

8. JBBQ & Shabu Shabu

Address: 11 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Phone: (631) 647-7777


If you're craving Japanese barbecue or the interactive dining experience of shabu-shabu, JBBQ & Shabu Shabu in Bay Shore is the place to be. Cook your own meats and vegetables at your table, and savor the rich flavors of Japanese cuisine. Well worth the money - Staff is polite and helpful. Great experience if looking for something different. Marinated Ribeye is to die for... don't forget to use the butter! Word of advice - The portions are LARGE and it is all-you-can-eat, so don't go overboard or you'll eat yourself to oblivion! DO make sure to try everything though. Loads of fun to experience with the entire family. Happy to also note that the quality is consistent! Make sure to check them out when hungry and in the neighborhood.


 

9. NY Axe Throwing Range

Address: 11 Michael Ave, Farmingdale, NY 11735

Phone: (631) 237-0050


Unleash your inner warrior and try your hand at axe throwing at the NY Axe Throwing Range in Farmingdale. This unique entertainment venue offers a thrilling experience where you can compete with friends or simply blow off some steam. Wonderful experiences here! I'd been axe throwing before while on tour; however not at home - So I decided to visit NY Axe. The staff was fantastic, very knowledgeable, and dare I say extremely entertaining! Had Rei as the AXEpert instructor who was a complete star - He was fun, playful and most importantly... ensured our safety, learning how to throw properly. They also offer Safe Archery! Overall - VERY recommended. Perfect for beginners, intermediate or advanced. **Also if you are feeling randy - you can toss Ninja Throwing Stars too! Extremely cool place. WIN.


 

10. East Bay Diner Seaford

Address: 3360 Merrick Rd, Seaford, NY 11783

Phone: (516) 781-5300


For classic American comfort food and an inviting atmosphere, head to East Bay Diner Seaford in Seaford. From all-day breakfast options to juicy burgers and hearty sandwiches, this diner has it all. Everything is seriously fantastic! Hands down a GREAT diner experience. My server was spectacular - on point, attentive, helpful and friendly! Honestly, the guy could give a seminar. My double burger is always cooked to perfection, my deep fried home fries I requested were ridiculously delicious... crispy and not burned! Coffee is smooth and delightful. The location itself is also visually stimulating with an underwater theme and I truly enjoy it to the fullest extent. Recommended.


 

11. Green Street Eatery

Address: 7 Emerson Ave, Levittown, NY 11756

Phone: (516) 806-2557